London's Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed a nearly £2B ($2.6B) class action against Sony in its entirety on Tuesday, Nov. 17.
The case was brought by consumer campaigner Alex Neill on behalf of an estimated 12.2M UK PlayStation users who bought digital games and add-ons.
The class covered purchases made between August 2016 and February 2026.
Claimants argued that forcing all digital content through the PlayStation Store, plus a 30% commission on developers, left buyers trapped in an ecosystem with no retail competition.
Their lawyers put the overcharge at around 20% versus what a competitive market would have delivered.
"Sony can and does set the retail prices ... without facing any retail competition for digital content. It allows it to obtain monopoly profits from digital distribution."
Lawyers for the claimant class, in March
The tribunal rejected both dominance and excessive pricing
Judges found the claimants failed to show Sony held a dominant position, pointing to rival gaming platforms and physical game sales.
The tribunal called the market definitions used an unsafe way to assess Sony's conduct.
It ruled that Sony competes in a wider systems market against Xbox, Nintendo, and PC, and has no legal duty to let third-party stores onto its console.
Opening the platform would be expensive, complex, and carry security risks, the tribunal noted.
On pricing, it found no evidence that Sony's profit margins were excessive or that rival storefronts would have pushed prices down.
The judgment also said console buyers had enough information and incentive to make informed choices, including about game prices.
Sony's defense was that the walled garden pays for the hardware
Sony told the court it had invested years and billions in an integrated platform, and that letting third parties sell on PlayStation would amount to free-riding.
The company sells consoles at a relatively low margin to build its user base, then uses store commissions to cross-subsidize that cost.
Sony sold 8M PlayStation 5 consoles globally between October and December 2025.
Sony Interactive Entertainment's senior vice president and general counsel Stephanie Burns said the ruling affirms the company's business model.
The decision lands amid Britain's growing collective action regime against big technology companies.
It was the third case against a major technology company to reach trial since the start of 2025.
The same tribunal ruled against Apple over its App Store in October last year, a decision Apple is appealing.
A claim against chipmaker Qualcomm was withdrawn after trial but before a ruling, and a Google trial began in October.
Fortnite maker Epic Games dropped out of the Google case after the search company announced changes to its Play Store practices.
The reasoning here could shape similar suits against Valve and other PC storefronts, where rivals like the Epic store and GOG already exist.
The ruling leaves Sony's business model intact, and PlayStation is under no legal duty to let third-party stores onto the platform.

