Manchester United is one of the world's most famous soccer clubs, but owning its stock is a different game from owning the team.
The club fired coach Michael Carrick on Nov. 12, replacing him with US men's national team coach Mauricio Pochettino as it sits 18th in the Premier League. For investors drawn to sports franchises, United offers a lesson in the difference between owning a valuable asset and making money from it.
Shareholders don't call the shots
The Glazer family bought Manchester United in a debt-funded takeover in 2005 before listing it in New York in 2012. They were early among American owners buying English soccer clubs, a group that now includes Stan Kroenke at Arsenal and John Henry at Liverpool.
Public Class A shares carry one vote each, while the Glazers and co-owner Jim Ratcliffe hold Class B shares with 10 votes apiece. That leaves the family with roughly 67% of voting power despite owning less than half the economic interest.
The arrangement has paid off for the owners. Sportico estimates the Glazers have taken out more than $1.3B through dividends, fees, loans, compensation, and share sales. Meanwhile, the club has spent roughly $1B on interest, bank fees, and debt repayments under their ownership.
Forbes valued United at $3.69B in 2017, ranking it third among the world's most valuable sports teams. Today, it's worth an estimated $6.6B but ranks just 24th. Investors seeking similar exposure have few alternatives, with Atlanta Braves Holdings among the rare publicly traded franchises.
Revenue climbs but profits disappear
United's fiscal first-quarter revenue rose 4.1% to $196M, helped by its return to the Champions League. Broadcasting revenue jumped 17.7% to $47.2M, while sponsorships and merchandise brought in $113M and matchday sales contributed $36M.
Commercial Deals Still Carry Manchester United's Revenue
Fiscal Q1 2027 revenue by stream, $M, three months to Sept. 30, 2026. Pounds converted at 1.3422
Bar chart. Revenue ($M). Commercial: Revenue ($M) $113. Broadcasting: Revenue ($M) $47.2. Matchday: Revenue ($M) $36.
Source: Manchester United Q1 FY2027 results, Sky Sports: Manchester United Q1 FY2027 results
Unfortunately, expenses are moving faster. Employee costs climbed 8.6% to $107M, pushing the club into a $4.03M operating loss from a $17.4M profit a year earlier. Its quarterly net loss widened to $24.3M.
Debt adds another headache. Noncurrent borrowings stood at $775M in September, while total obligations reached roughly $1.5B once credit facilities and unpaid player transfers are included.
United also wants to build a 100K-seat stadium, requiring an estimated $1B to $3B in financing. The club plans to fund it privately, unlike the taxpayer-supported stadium deals common in American sports.
Wall Street sees a discount
Despite the financial baggage, two American funds see an opportunity. Ariel Investments owns 9.2M Class A shares and believes MANU trades roughly 30% below private-market valuations. Gabelli's Opportunities in Live & Sports ETF has allocated 5.4% of its portfolio to the club, while analyst Alec Boccanfuso estimates a sale could fetch about $7B.
Their case rests on the premiums wealthy buyers have historically paid for prestigious sports franchises. The problem is that Manchester United's performance hasn't matched its reputation.
Carrick became the seventh full-time coach dismissed in roughly a decade, United hasn't won the Premier League since 2013, and relegation would mark its first drop to a lower division since 1974.
Player spending hasn't delivered much relief either. The club's payroll ranks 11th in Europe, while revenue has grown around 5.5% annually since listing and operating profits have declined. With no Premier League salary cap, keeping up with rivals remains expensive.
Management insists the business can withstand disappointing results. Co-owner Avram Glazer has argued that performance on the field doesn't determine United's commercial appeal, while CEO Omar Berrada says revenue remains on track.
For public investors, the bigger obstacle is control. The estimated 30% valuation gap means little without a sale, and the Glazers have no obligation to give minority shareholders an exit.
Manchester United may be worth billions to whoever controls it. Everyone else is paying for a seat in the stands while the owners keep the keys to the stadium.

