Gaming Trends

GameStop Investors Pivot to Nintendo After Roaring Kitty’s Viral Tweet

By Rhea Lobo
GameStop Investors Pivot to Nintendo After Roaring Kitty’s Viral Tweet

Roaring Kitty is back, just as the biggest video game launch in years shows how much GameStop has changed. Keith Gill returned to X on Nov. 19 with a picture of a cat dressed as Mario, his first post since January 2025.

The timing coincided with Take-Two Interactive's Grand Theft Auto VI release, but Nintendo's American depositary receipts attracted stronger buying. The irony is that the blockbuster driving all this excitement barely needs a physical game store.

GTA VI has no use for discs

Grand Theft Auto VI arrived as a download, while its retail edition contains a redemption code rather than a disc. Sensor Tower estimates digital preorders nearly doubled in under two weeks, climbing from 7.71M on Nov. 3 to 14.94M by Nov. 16, worth approximately $1.45B.

Sony plans to stop manufacturing physical discs for new PlayStation games in 2028, accelerating a transition already well underway. Digital purchases account for 85% of full-game sales on PlayStation.

That's particularly painful for GameStop, which historically made money buying and reselling used games. Pre-owned and refurbished products contributed roughly $171M in the quarter ending Aug. 1, down 32% from a year earlier and accounting for just 22% of sales.

Cohen wants ownership back

GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen has been outspoken about publishers abandoning physical releases. Speaking to Bloomberg days before GTA VI's $80 digital-only launch, he argued that consumers should retain the ability to resell their purchases.

"When you buy a game, you should be able to sell it, trade it or lend it to a friend."

Ryan Cohen, GameStop

Publishers see those transactions differently. Every secondhand copy potentially replaces a new sale, giving developers little reason to preserve a resale market. New York Democratic Rep. Ritchie Torres has backed the Power to the Players Act, which would require continued access to purchased games.

Trading cards replace video games

GameStop isn't waiting for the industry to reverse course. Collectibles, particularly Pokémon trading cards, now account for 41% of quarterly revenue, compared with just 18% for software, which includes physical and digital games.

Collectibles Now Outsell Games at GameStop

Share of GameStop revenue by category, most recent reported quarter, %

Pie chart. Collectibles: Revenue Mix (%) 41%. Software: Revenue Mix (%) 18%. Hardware and other: Revenue Mix (%) 41%.

Source: TNW, Bloomberg

The company has also closed more than 1.3K stores over two fiscal years, shrinking its retail footprint as traditional game sales decline.

Cohen acknowledged the transformation in July, telling Bloomberg TV that falling physical game sales were irrelevant to GameStop's future. His attention had already shifted toward acquiring eBay.

GameStop's biggest bet isn't gaming

GameStop reported $4.85B in cash and another $206M in short-term investments in its latest quarter. Its eBay stake was valued at approximately $4.9B in September, representing roughly 43.4M shares acquired for $4.39B.

Against those assets sits approximately $2.8B in convertible debt. GameStop also tried to acquire eBay outright earlier this year, but its unsolicited $56B proposal was rejected in May. Its ownership position has since approached 8%.

Meanwhile, Take-Two is collecting the proceeds from a gaming industry that increasingly bypasses retailers. Sensor Tower estimates GTA VI sold 19.1M copies by Thursday morning, generating nearly $2B in first-day revenue.

That leaves GameStop shareholders betting less on video games and more on Cohen's investment decisions. The company now owns billions in cash and eBay shares alongside a shrinking store network increasingly devoted to collectibles. Roaring Kitty can still get traders excited with a picture, but the real story is what Cohen does with the money.