Oversight Probe

Raskin Demands Federal Compliance on Record Retention

By Finks Desk
Raskin Demands Federal Compliance on Record Retention

Rep. Jamie Raskin, the top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee and its incoming chairman, opened a records investigation into official business conducted on Signal and other nongovernment messaging apps, sending near-identical preservation letters to the Justice Department, the FBI, Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the Bureau of Prisons.

The letters demand that each agency preserve official communications, including those on personal devices, open an inquiry into whether records were improperly deleted and recover what they can from backups and metadata.

They cover records the committee has sought since Jan. 20, 2025, and Raskin asked all five agency heads to certify compliance by Dec. 3, adding to the records demands Democrats have sent since the midterms.

The evidence is a disappearing chat

The case Raskin put front and center is a Signal exchange between FBI General Counsel Samuel Ramer and Drew Lynch, an associate of Donald Trump Jr., about a potential or ongoing health care fraud case involving someone federal authorities have been seeking.

A screenshot Raskin appended to his letter to Attorney General Todd Blanche shows the messages were set to disappear after one week, and Raskin called the exchange one of many incidents already reported to the committee.

"The FBI's top lawyer should be ensuring that all 35,000 FBI employees are preserving government and law enforcement records."

Jamie Raskin, House Judiciary Committee

Both sides are building a legal record

The Justice Department said it follows all legal requirements for managing federal records tied to its official functions, and a White House official said the administration complies with all federal record retention laws.

White House Counsel Will Scharf went further, telling Democratic committee leaders that ranking member requests don't trigger any obligation to accommodate because Democrats don't hold the gavels yet.

That changes in January, when Democrats take over the committees they won in the Nov. 3 midterms, a shift that has its own blue wave trade for investors. Until then they lack subpoena power, so the letters work mainly as a paper trail.

"It's the type of thing that a future Department of Justice could use as evidence in court of intent to destroy records," said Jim Secreto, who worked in the Obama White House Counsel's office.

The issue reaches well beyond federal agencies. Encrypted apps have been spreading through government for years, and an Associated Press review found accounts registered to cellphone numbers for over 1.1K government workers and elected officials across all 50 states.

Federal recordkeeping rules still apply to messages on third-party apps, including those sent from personal accounts, and the National Archives has warned that auto-deletion can violate them.

The administration is pushing back in kind. On Thursday, US Attorney Aaron Reitz sent Raskin his own preservation demand, accusing him of pursuing investigations with no legislative purpose, which makes Dec. 3 the first test of whether the five agency heads certify compliance or decline.